Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

ComicBook Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Is Lanterns Really Not Connecting With Audiences? What Did You Think?

Featured Replies

  • CB Team

There's been a lot of discussion about the future of Lanterns following the shakeup at DC Studios.

Variety reported that an insider felt the show wasn't quite capturing the cultural zeitgeist, despite drawing some pretty strong viewership numbers. That led to reports that the series was canceled, although it's since been clarified that a second season simply hasn't been renewed yet.

I find that interesting because there's obviously a difference between a show getting good ratings and becoming something everyone is talking about.

For those who watched Lanterns, what did you think of it? Did you enjoy the story and the direction they took Hal Jordan and John Stewart? And do you think the show deserves a second season, or would you rather see DC take these characters in a different direction?

  • Replies 77
  • Views 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Seems to be connecting with audiences to me. I have not watched it myself yet, but the reaction to it appears genuinely positive.

  • We had DC Podcast Host telling any 1 that did not like Lanterns say stuff like 'Lanterns' Critics 'Aren't Worth Living' & much more fun things u call that connecting or well received ? Also it fa

  • & James Done said he would originally never hire Damon Lindelof woke & racist & hateful activist Less start with the woke & racist & hateful activists that the woke & racist &a

Posted Images

Seems to be connecting with audiences to me. I have not watched it myself yet, but the reaction to it appears genuinely positive.

That wasn't exactly constructive criticism.

It can be received well without every single person in the world falling in love with it.

3 hours ago, FantasticJerome said:

What exactly do you disagree with? I'm just curious how people feel about the show compared to what's being reported.

We had DC Podcast Host telling any 1 that did not like Lanterns say stuff like 'Lanterns' Critics 'Aren't Worth Living' & much more fun things

u call that connecting or well received ? Also it failed in viewership where it matters on Nielsen

2 hours ago, RoosterCold said:

That wasn't exactly constructive criticism.

It can be received well without every single person in the world falling in love with it.

We had DC Podcast Host telling any 1 that did not like Lanterns say stuff like 'Lanterns' Critics 'Aren't Worth Living' & much more fun things

u call that connecting or well received ? Also it failed in viewership where it matters on Nielsen

& James Done said he would originally never hire Damon Lindelof

woke & racist & hateful activist

Less start with the woke & racist & hateful activists that the woke & racist & hateful activist James Done surrounds himself with

Edited by ItsOver9000

  • Author
  • CB Team

I think you may have misunderstood my original post. I'm not defending Lanterns or suggesting everyone has to like it. Everyone I've personally talked to about the show has enjoyed it, which is actually part of why I found the reports interesting.

I was curious whether others felt the same way and whether there's really a disconnect between the show's viewership and its overall cultural impact. That's why I started the discussion. I'm interested in hearing both positive and negative opinions.

One podcast host is not really indicative of much. Also, Nielsen may matter to television execs, but not here. Nielsen is only a small subsection of things because not every household is a Nielsen household, so the data is incomplete.

The show's future is precarious due to leadership changes, not necessarily one individual. I never put much stock in the word "woke", particularly online.

Let me be clear, Jerome, I am defending Lanterns.

What I want to know is where the money for the budget went. A show about Green Lantern but there were barely any constructs.

Also: the show ended exactly the way it started, and it did nothing for the larger DCU. Not like it matters now anyways LOL.


1 hour ago, NinDiego_64 said:

What I want to know is where the money for the budget went. A show about Green Lantern but there were barely any constructs.

Also: the show ended exactly the way it started, and it did nothing for the larger DCU. Not like it matters now anyways LOL.

They turned California into Nebraska or whatever with CGI. They removed trees & hills & added trees & hills etc per episode

  • Author
  • CB Team
13 hours ago, NinDiego_64 said:

What I want to know is where the money for the budget went. A show about Green Lantern but there were barely any constructs.

Also: the show ended exactly the way it started, and it did nothing for the larger DCU. Not like it matters now anyways LOL.

That's an interesting point about the constructs. Considering how much of Green Lantern's appeal comes from what the rings can create, I can understand why their limited use would disappoint some fans.

Do you think that was primarily a budget decision, or were they deliberately trying to keep the series more grounded?

  • Author
  • CB Team

I actually looked into this, and apparently a pretty substantial amount of CGI went into turning California into Nebraska. They reportedly had around 2,350 VFX shots across the eight episodes, with a lot of that work involving replacing mountains, skies, and other background elements.

I can see how that would get expensive, especially when you're doing it across an entire season. I do wonder whether filming somewhere that already resembled Nebraska would have been more cost-effective, though I imagine there were logistical reasons for staying in California.

Still, I can understand the disappointment about the lack of constructs. When you're watching a Green Lantern series, that's naturally something you'd expect to see more of.

An initial season of a Green Lantern show really shouldn't be too heavy with things like that. There is still a lot of exposition that needs to be set up. The GLC is really only going to use constructs during fights. I doubt we will be getting an itinerary for the budget.

I don't think anyone has any issues with anybody posting constructive criticism here. We probably welcome it, actually. I have not even actually watched it myself yet.

The show is also called Lanterns, which gives me the impression that they are going to use more than one GL, if not the entire Corps. That could be a large budget in and of itself.

Series like this, movies too, prefer to build up gradually to those sorts of things. There is so much content for this to work through. Throwing a lot of it out there all at once is likely not a very good idea.

  • Author
  • CB Team

That's a good point about building things up gradually. There's so much Green Lantern mythology to explore that I can see why they wouldn't want to introduce everything at once.

I'd love to see them eventually bring in some of the other Lantern Corps, too. The Red Lanterns, Blue Lanterns, and especially the Sinestro Corps could open up some really interesting storylines. I think seeing those different powers and how they interact would be pretty incredible.

If the series gets another season, I'd be curious whether they'll expand into that side of the mythology or continue keeping things relatively grounded.

1 hour ago, RoosterCold said:

An initial season of a Green Lantern show really shouldn't be too heavy with things like that. There is still a lot of exposition that needs to be set up. The GLC is really only going to use constructs during fights. I doubt we will be getting an itinerary for the budget.

I don't think anyone has any issues with anybody posting constructive criticism here. We probably welcome it, actually. I have not even actually watched it myself yet.

The show is also called Lanterns, which gives me the impression that they are going to use more than one GL, if not the entire Corps. That could be a large budget in and of itself.

Series like this, movies too, prefer to build up gradually to those sorts of things. There is so much content for this to work through. Throwing a lot of it out there all at once is likely not a very good idea.

Superman (2025) only took two minutes to set up the world. Tom Holland Spider-Man has never mentioned uncle Ben not even once. We’re at a stage in the zeitgeist where no one cares about origins. Green Lantern is not on the same stage as let’s say polkadot man. People tuning in for a Green Lantern show want to watch Green Lantern things. Not two dudes in a car discussing who’s better suited for a job. Although I’m not sure if you would be familiar with that if you didn’t see the show.

This is a different project. They don't all need to follow the same formula, nor should they.

If Lanterns does not get cancelled, of course we will get all of this in due time. It will probably follow a very similar path to GL:TAS.

Superman didn't set up everything. Superman has even more history than GL, what they did in that movie was good, but a far cry from "everything". All that means is that Spider-Man hasn't set up everything either, and Uncle Ben has been indirectly mentioned a few times.

Doesn't matter what people care about, they aren't the ones creating the project. Until the entire universe is set up, GL is on the same stage as Polka Dot Man, every character is. People tuning in for a GL show would only be doing so because of name recognition, there would be no way to know anything else about the show. Again, it doesn't even matter what people are tuning in for. What matters is the story they want to tell and they have final say, not us.

1 hour ago, RoosterCold said:

This is a different project. They don't all need to follow the same formula, nor should they.

If Lanterns does not get cancelled, of course we will get all of this in due time. It will probably follow a very similar path to GL:TAS.

Superman didn't set up everything. Superman has even more history than GL, what they did in that movie was good, but a far cry from "everything". All that means is that Spider-Man hasn't set up everything either, and Uncle Ben has been indirectly mentioned a few times.

Doesn't matter what people care about, they aren't the ones creating the project. Until the entire universe is set up, GL is on the same stage as Polka Dot Man, every character is. People tuning in for a GL show would only be doing so because of name recognition, there would be no way to know anything else about the show. Again, it doesn't even matter what people are tuning in for. What matters is the story they want to tell and they have final say, not us.

We decide what is a success & failure

& Lanterns failed as did the dcu as a whole

2 hours ago, RoosterCold said:

This is a different project. They don't all need to follow the same formula, nor should they.

If Lanterns does not get cancelled, of course we will get all of this in due time. It will probably follow a very similar path to GL:TAS.

Superman didn't set up everything. Superman has even more history than GL, what they did in that movie was good, but a far cry from "everything". All that means is that Spider-Man hasn't set up everything either, and Uncle Ben has been indirectly mentioned a few times.

Doesn't matter what people care about, they aren't the ones creating the project. Until the entire universe is set up, GL is on the same stage as Polka Dot Man, every character is. People tuning in for a GL show would only be doing so because of name recognition, there would be no way to know anything else about the show. Again, it doesn't even matter what people are tuning in for. What matters is the story they want to tell and they have final say, not us.

Never said Superman set up "everything" he just set the stage for that universe with the whole 3 minutes, 300 years thing.

Have to immensely disagree with you there. The people cared enough online to make the bean counters notice and that's why James Gunn is gone. If you think Green Lantern and Polka Dot Man are on the same stage then idk dude you haven't been paying attention, and you're contradicting yourself in saying they're on the same stage but admitting that people are tuning in to a GL show for name recognition. That does not sound like an even playing field with these two characters to me.

And audiences decided the story sucked. I think you'd know that if you watch it.

image.png

Supergirl got a better rating and that is more generally hated.

image.png

  • Author
  • CB Team
5 hours ago, NinDiego_64 said:

Never said Superman set up "everything" he just set the stage for that universe with the whole 3 minutes, 300 years thing.

Have to immensely disagree with you there. The people cared enough online to make the bean counters notice and that's why James Gunn is gone. If you think Green Lantern and Polka Dot Man are on the same stage then idk dude you haven't been paying attention, and you're contradicting yourself in saying they're on the same stage but admitting that people are tuning in to a GL show for name recognition. That does not sound like an even playing field with these two characters to me.

And audiences decided the story sucked. I think you'd know that if you watch it.

image.png

Supergirl got a better rating and that is more generally hated.

image.png

What did you think of Supergirl? I haven't seen it but was curious before I spend time watching it. I've read Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow and liked it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.