Tuesday at 12:11 AM2 days 10 minutes ago, FantasticJerome said:What did you think of Supergirl? I haven't seen it but was curious before I spend time watching it. I've read Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow and liked it.Its nothing like said comic. Even Grace Randolph & Angry Joe hated it
Tuesday at 12:26 AM2 days Yeah, I would try not to inflate your own importance too much, and a movie has no obligation to be like a comic book. These seem like rather meme heavy responses. They also don't have a lot of meat to them, I'm afraid.One line is enough to give some backstory and maybe a thesis to play around with. It is not that major until some more details are filled in. James Gunn being gone didnt really have anything to do with that, that was a structural change result. You saying I'm contradicting myself doesnt mean anything. You're the one who selected Polka Dot Man, not me. You have to live with the consequences of that.Rotten Tomatoes also isn't exactly the be all end all. It's not like you got the final word on the subject because you posted Rotten Tomatoes.
Tuesday at 01:24 AM1 day 1 hour ago, FantasticJerome said:What did you think of Supergirl? I haven't seen it but was curious before I spend time watching it. I've read Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow and liked it.I thought it was mid. The hate was overblown but the movie itself was nothing to celebrate either.
Tuesday at 01:55 PM1 day 13 hours ago, RoosterCold said:Yeah, I would try not to inflate your own importance too much, and a movie has no obligation to be like a comic book. These seem like rather meme heavy responses. They also don't have a lot of meat to them, I'm afraid.One line is enough to give some backstory and maybe a thesis to play around with. It is not that major until some more details are filled in.James Gunn being gone didnt really have anything to do with that, that was a structural change result. You saying I'm contradicting myself doesnt mean anything. You're the one who selected Polka Dot Man, not me. You have to live with the consequences of that.Rotten Tomatoes also isn't exactly the be all end all. It's not like you got the final word on the subject because you posted Rotten Tomatoes.What I'm getting from this response is a lot of hand-waving and very little engagement with the actual point.You told me not to "inflate my own importance," yet the entire entertainment industry spends billions tracking audience reactions because audience interest literally determines whether projects succeed or fail. If audience opinions were as irrelevant as you're suggesting, studios wouldn't obsess over ratings, box office numbers, streaming data, social media engagement, or market research.The contradiction is still there. You argued Green Lantern is on the same level as Polka-Dot Man, then immediately acknowledged people are tuning in because of Green Lantern's name recognition. Those two statements don't coexist very well. A character with decades of mainstream exposure, multiple animated series, movies, video games, and Justice League appearances is obviously not operating from the same baseline as a niche Suicide Squad supporting character.As for Rotten Tomatoes, nobody said it was the final word. The problem is that whenever the audience score is positive it's evidence people like the show, but whenever it's negative suddenly it doesn't matter. That's not an argument; that's just moving the goalposts.And the James Gunn point wasn't even the centerpiece of my argument. The centerpiece was that audience reaction absolutely influences corporate decisions, which history has demonstrated repeatedly.At this point it feels less like you're rebutting what I said and more like you're dismissing evidence because it points in a direction you don't like. Saying something is "meme-heavy" doesn't make it wrong. That's not a counterargument, it's a label.
Tuesday at 02:36 PM1 day 39 minutes ago, NinDiego_64 said:What I'm getting from this response is a lot of hand-waving and very little engagement with the actual point.You told me not to "inflate my own importance," yet the entire entertainment industry spends billions tracking audience reactions because audience interest literally determines whether projects succeed or fail. If audience opinions were as irrelevant as you're suggesting, studios wouldn't obsess over ratings, box office numbers, streaming data, social media engagement, or market research.The contradiction is still there. You argued Green Lantern is on the same level as Polka-Dot Man, then immediately acknowledged people are tuning in because of Green Lantern's name recognition. Those two statements don't coexist very well. A character with decades of mainstream exposure, multiple animated series, movies, video games, and Justice League appearances is obviously not operating from the same baseline as a niche Suicide Squad supporting character.As for Rotten Tomatoes, nobody said it was the final word. The problem is that whenever the audience score is positive it's evidence people like the show, but whenever it's negative suddenly it doesn't matter. That's not an argument; that's just moving the goalposts.And the James Gunn point wasn't even the centerpiece of my argument. The centerpiece was that audience reaction absolutely influences corporate decisions, which history has demonstrated repeatedly.At this point it feels less like you're rebutting what I said and more like you're dismissing evidence because it points in a direction you don't like. Saying something is "meme-heavy" doesn't make it wrong. That's not a counterargument, it's a label. RoosterCold has no evidenceLanterns failed where it matters & only matters on the Nielsen charts
Tuesday at 02:46 PM1 day 8 minutes ago, ItsOver9000 said:RoosterCold has no evidenceLanterns failed where it matters & only matters on the Nielsen chartsIt’s obnoxious to try to have a good faith argument with someone and their rebuttals are just nonsense.
Tuesday at 03:29 PM1 day 42 minutes ago, NinDiego_64 said:It’s obnoxious to try to have a good faith argument with someone and their rebuttals are just nonsense.the results speak 4 themselves with james done getting shit canned
Tuesday at 06:20 PM1 day Author CB Team In that case, maybe they will give Lanterns another shot in the future, but with a different angle.
23 hours ago23 hr At this point it sounds like you're just complaining just to complain. That isn't worth arguing against. Nobody cares that much about what you're saying. Either have a conversation like a grown up or don't have one at all. We're talking about something, not having a rap battle. Keep the insults out of it.
23 hours ago23 hr Just now, RoosterCold said:At this point it sounds like you're just complaining just to complain. That isn't worth arguing against. Nobody cares that much about what you're saying. Either have a conversation like a grown up or don't have one at all. We're talking about something, not having a rap battle. Keep the insults out of it.Dude what the FUCK are you talking about?
22 hours ago22 hr 1 hour ago, RoosterCold said:That's what I'm talking about. Thank you for perfectly illustrating it.At this point it sounds like you're just complaining just to complain. That isn't worth arguing against. Nobody cares that much about what you're saying. Either have a conversation like a grown up or don't have one at all. We're talking about something, not having a rap battle. Keep the insults out of it.
21 hours ago21 hr 1 hour ago, RoosterCold said:That's what I'm talking about. Thank you for perfectly illustrating it.So you’re a troll. Got it.
21 hours ago21 hr 26 minutes ago, ItsOver9000 said:At this point it sounds like you're just complaining just to complain. That isn't worth arguing against. Nobody cares that much about what you're saying. Either have a conversation like a grown up or don't have one at all. We're talking about something, not having a rap battle. Keep the insults out of it.Don’t even bother, dudes a terrible bot or just really bad at trolling.
20 hours ago20 hr Author CB Team Alright guys, I think we've gone back and forth on this enough. It's probably time to move on from the argument.We all seem to be comic fans here and we're not always going to agree on everything. That's part of what makes these discussions interesting.Let's just try to be cordial to each other and keep things friendly. There's no reason for any of this to get personal. This is all supposed to be fun!
20 hours ago20 hr 1 hour ago, NinDiego_64 said:Don’t even bother, dudes a terrible bot or just really bad at trolling.so how many alt bot accounts u got in this thread & or forum ?
13 hours ago13 hr 7 hours ago, FantasticJerome said:Alright guys, I think we've gone back and forth on this enough. It's probably time to move on from the argument.We all seem to be comic fans here and we're not always going to agree on everything. That's part of what makes these discussions interesting.Let's just try to be cordial to each other and keep things friendly. There's no reason for any of this to get personal. This is all supposed to be fun!I don't know something strange is going on with whatever is happening here. This is the only thread I have ever seen since I first started posting here make it to a page two and it is also the only thread I have ever seen in which it is not just mostly you and I. That does not feel like a coincidence to me.
11 hours ago11 hr 8 hours ago, ItsOver9000 said:the projection wowI’m not calling you a troll, I’m calling the other guy a troll.
11 hours ago11 hr 8 hours ago, ItsOver9000 said:so how many alt bot accounts u got in this thread & or forum ?22, not counting this one. AI TAKING OVER.
11 hours ago11 hr 1 hour ago, RoosterCold said:I don't know something strange is going on with whatever is happening here. This is the only thread I have ever seen since I first started posting here make it to a page two and it is also the only thread I have ever seen in which it is not just mostly you and I. That does not feel like a coincidence to me.I’m trying to inject life into this forum. Crazy huh.
11 hours ago11 hr 1 hour ago, RoosterCold said:I don't know something strange is going on with whatever is happening here. This is the only thread I have ever seen since I first started posting here make it to a page two and it is also the only thread I have ever seen in which it is not just mostly you and I. That does not feel like a coincidence to me.Plus you suck at trying to argue.
11 hours ago11 hr 9 hours ago, FantasticJerome said:Alright guys, I think we've gone back and forth on this enough. It's probably time to move on from the argument.We all seem to be comic fans here and we're not always going to agree on everything. That's part of what makes these discussions interesting.Let's just try to be cordial to each other and keep things friendly. There's no reason for any of this to get personal. This is all supposed to be fun!I'm not trying to get personal with anyone. I made my points against Rooster's claims and he's the one that went off the grid saying I was rapping. If anything, because I'm a brown skinned individual, that has a slight hint of racism in it. Look me in my virtual eye and tell me Rooster was arguing in good faith. He wasn't.
11 hours ago11 hr Author CB Team Just to clarify something, I've seen accusations about bot accounts and people using multiple accounts in this thread. I'm not aware of any evidence supporting those claims, and I don't want anyone getting the wrong impression about the forum.I'm actually one of the moderators here, and if anyone has legitimate concerns about another member or account, please feel free to reach out privately so we can look into it.I appreciate everyone participating and helping make the forum more active. That's exactly what we're trying to accomplish. I just want us to be able to disagree without things getting personal.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.