With Brand New Day about to give us another Tom Holland movie, who is your favorite of the three? It's really hard to look past the nostalgic love I have for the first two Maguire movies (especially with how well Spider-Man 2 holds up). He has the most iconic moments, and he's particularly great as Peter Parker. Garfield is underrated because the movies weren't good, but he's probably slightly better as Spider-Man than Maguire was (and certainly funnier/quippier). But... I think Holland might've overtaken them both for me as he just gets almost everything right (the only drawback has been the reliance on other MCU characters in shaping him).

It's always gonna be Tobey for me. That's the one I grew up with.

Honestly? Probably Holland. I grew up with Tobey but I liked the rest of the package more than I liked Peter himself. Holland's the first one where I've really liked Peter. Probably helps that we've gotten so much more of Holland's Peter

Until No Way Home, it was probably Andrew Garfield, but after his growth in that film, it's probably Holland now.

Tobey McGuire.