January 22Jan 22 CB Team Some characters feel like they change wildly depending on who’s writing them, and not always for the better.Is there a comic character you love (or want to love) that you feel is often miswritten, misunderstood, or handled inconsistently? What do you think writers tend to get wrong about them?
January 24Jan 24 CB Team 23 hours ago, Comicbookfan101 said:I think the joker.I actually agree here. For me it's a matter of wild inconsistency.
January 26Jan 26 CB Team The Joker is probably the right answer, given how inconsistent he can be.That said, there are a handful of characters I feel writers struggle to get right. Iron Man, for instance. Or the Punisher. And since that unfortunate storyline, no one knows how to handle Hank Pym... Actually, now that I think about it, I feel that the nature of a decades-long storyline makes CONSISTENT character the exception, not the rule. One more reason to love Daredevil.
January 26Jan 26 CB Team Iron Man seems like one that flies under that radar.Given the character's arc of an arms dealer who gives it up but also becomes his greatest living weapon, I feel like there's a lot of repetition that comes with him.
January 27Jan 27 Author CB Team On 1/22/2026 at 6:51 PM, Comicbookfan101 said:I think the joker.I can agree with that one for sure.
January 27Jan 27 Author CB Team On 1/23/2026 at 4:27 AM, MAG said:Shang Chi --- the Master of Kung FuiGood choice! I'll have to admit, I haven't read much of Shang Chi, but I do like the character.
January 27Jan 27 Author CB Team 9 hours ago, Marco Vito Oddo said:The Joker is probably the right answer, given how inconsistent he can be.That said, there are a handful of characters I feel writers struggle to get right. Iron Man, for instance. Or the Punisher. And since that unfortunate storyline, no one knows how to handle Hank Pym... Actually, now that I think about it, I feel that the nature of a decades-long storyline makes CONSISTENT character the exception, not the rule. One more reason to love Daredevil.I can imagine it's tough to keep all characters consistent, especially those who've been around so long. Also, I'm sure there are many writers who write characters without doing enough research and that probably contributes to some issues.
January 27Jan 27 Author CB Team 4 hours ago, saperry said:Iron Man seems like one that flies under that radar.Given the character's arc of an arms dealer who gives it up but also becomes his greatest living weapon, I feel like there's a lot of repetition that comes with him.Yep, I can see that. I read Iron Man comics as a kid, but got bored with him easily.
January 27Jan 27 CB Team I think if we're being really honest, most characters are consistently miswritten but that is largely an issue of shifting editorial mandate and creative ideas of individual writers. That's not necessarily a bad thing, just something that I think we see more of than we really realize.
January 28Jan 28 CB Team 8 hours ago, Nicole Drum said:I think if we're being really honest, most characters are consistently miswritten but that is largely an issue of shifting editorial mandate and creative ideas of individual writers. That's not necessarily a bad thing, just something that I think we see more of than we really realize.For sure, it also doesnt help that we have decades of comics at our fingertips these days so we can find the holes immediately.
January 28Jan 28 CB Team 1 hour ago, saperry said:For sure, it also doesnt help that we have decades of comics at our fingertips these days so we can find the holes immediately.And you know that there are nerds like me who gleefuly do so, lol.
January 28Jan 28 CB Team I feel like Red Hood and Huntress (one of my faves) are all over the place depending on which team is at the helm.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.