February 12Feb 12 CB Team If Disney decided to green light a full series order of The Muppet Show and put you in charge of putting together the guest star list, who would be the first celebs you call?I have been saying for years the easiest thing they could do is get Hugh Jackman to dance and sing on stage with Muppets. How that hasn't happened yet is beyond me.
February 12Feb 12 CB Team Chappell Roan, Dolly Parton (imagine the Jolene bit they could do with her, Miss Piggy, and Kermit), NPH, get Jason Segel back, and Michael Caine as himself but the Muppets all fully think he's Scrooge
February 12Feb 12 CB Team 3 hours ago, James Hunt said:Chappell Roan, Dolly Parton (imagine the Jolene bit they could do with her, Miss Piggy, and Kermit), NPH, get Jason Segel back, and Michael Caine as himself but the Muppets all fully think he's ScroogeJason Segel is a great idea, would honestly be perfect.Personally, I'd like to see Danny McBride appear
February 12Feb 12 Author CB Team Yeah, Segel would be cool. Bring back Walter too. I didn't see him on the special.
February 16Feb 16 CB Team On 2/12/2026 at 9:11 AM, James Hunt said:Chappell Roan, Dolly Parton (imagine the Jolene bit they could do with her, Miss Piggy, and Kermit), NPH, get Jason Segel back, and Michael Caine as himself but the Muppets all fully think he's ScroogeChappell Roan would be amazing!!!
February 18Feb 18 CB Team I'd love to see Ariana Grande. She's hilarious when she's on SNL, and you could also get some great performances.I also agree that Jason Segel would be fantastic. We just rewatched the Muppets movie, and it holds up so well!
February 20Feb 20 Chris Pratt would probably be a hilarious guest. He loves to be a total goofball at times. He would blend in perfectly with The Muppets.
February 22Feb 22 CB Team It's got to be someone who can both be funny and a musical guest. Wouldn't mind Bad Bunny showing up
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.